This episode challenges the conventional wisdom that ads need to be aesthetically polished to perform well. It argues that 'ugly ads' can often outperform highly produced creative, particularly on platforms like Meta, by focusing on authenticity, clear messaging, and direct communication with the customer. The key takeaway for ecommerce operators is to prioritize testing diverse ad creatives, including less polished options, to discover what truly resonates with their audience and drives conversions rather than getting caught up in production value.
Key takeaways
Experiment with 'ugly' or low-production-value ads, such as direct text messages, screenshots of positive reviews, or raw user-generated content, to see if they outperform polished creative.
Focus ad creative on clearly communicating the offer, resolving a customer pain point, or highlighting a unique selling proposition, rather than solely on aesthetics.
Utilize dynamic creative testing to efficiently identify which ad elements (headlines, copy, visuals) are most effective, even if they aren't 'beautiful.'
Don't be afraid to break traditional ad design rules; unconventional or 'native-looking' creatives can often bypass ad blindness and capture attention more effectively.
Prioritize ad effectiveness and conversion rates over subjective notions of beauty or brand perfection in your acquisition strategy.
"Make Ugly Ads."
It's on his hat. It's on his mic. It's on his wall.
Barry Hott isn't afraid to tell you as many times as you need to be told, and it's for a simple reason: he's right. Ugly ads work.
Barry has a lot of years in the ecommerce/DTC/paid social/growth marketing space, and I brought him on this episode ostensibly to discuss the how and why of ugly ads. But for two guys who just love talking shop it was impossible to keep ourselves from delving into all kinds of growth strategy and media buying specifics.
Strap in: Barry brought the energy and this is a fun one. Enjoy it, then go make some ugly ads.
EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS [00:00:14] Ugly ads strategy. [00:05:14] Ugly ads effectiveness. [00:07:52-00:08:02] Ugly ads effectiveness. [00:12:54-00:13:04] Socially native stills. [00:16:49-00:16:59] Fake UGC authenticity. [00:20:15-00:20:26] Ad Language Nuance. [00:25:51-00:26:02] Apparel ad strategies. [00:28:47] Personalized ad language. [00:33:27] Insecurity through advertising. [00:36:40] Cost to impact ratio. [00:39:45] Process vs Instincts [00:45:47-00:45:57] Ugly ad considerations. [00:47:42] Authenticity in advertising. [00:50:21] Creative platform expectations. EPISODE SPONSOR
Virtual assistants can be helpful, but virtual professionals can change your business. Recruit, onboard, and train incredible virtual professionals in the Philippines by visiting https://morenow.co/af.
FOLLOW UP WITH BARRY Get Barry's CreativeOS Ugly Ads Templates: https://www.creativeos.io/experts/barry Follow Barry on X: <a href="htt
What does this episode say about paid acquisition?
Experiment with 'ugly' or low-production-value ads, such as direct text messages, screenshots of positive reviews, or raw user-generated content, to see if they outperform polished creative.
What does this episode say about conversion & cro?
Focus ad creative on clearly communicating the offer, resolving a customer pain point, or highlighting a unique selling proposition, rather than solely on aesthetics.
What does this episode say about brand & content?
Utilize dynamic creative testing to efficiently identify which ad elements (headlines, copy, visuals) are most effective, even if they aren't 'beautiful.'
What does this episode say about paid acquisition?
Don't be afraid to break traditional ad design rules; unconventional or 'native-looking' creatives can often bypass ad blindness and capture attention more effectively.
What does this episode say about paid acquisition?
Prioritize ad effectiveness and conversion rates over subjective notions of beauty or brand perfection in your acquisition strategy.
