Modern Retail Podcast artwork

The new life cycle of a brand ‘cancellation’

Modern Retail Podcast · with Sam Gauchier · August 29, 2026 · 32 min

Summary

In today's social media-driven landscape, brand reputation is under constant scrutiny. This episode reveals why traditional crisis PR tactics, like silence or sweeping scandals under the rug, are now ineffective and can even amplify backlash. Ecommerce brands must proactively engage with consumer criticism and understand the long-term implications of boycotts.

Key takeaways

Themes

brand & contentdtc strategy

Topics covered

brand reputation managementsocial media backlashcrisis public relationsconsumer boycottsbrand transparency

Episode description

In an era where a brand's reputation is tethered to the relentless cycles of social media, silence is no longer a defensive strategy for brands and can even become a liability. In this episode of the Modern Retail Podcast, senior reporter Gabi Barkho is joined by crisis PR consultant Sam Gauchier to break down why the old-school public relations tactic of trying to sweep a major scandal under the rug is increasingly failing major brands. The latest example came this week, when Target quickly scrambled to do damage control after one of its children’s Halloween costumes was called out for its depiction of blackface. Neutrogena is also facing backlash in the wake of former ambassador Hayden Panettiere’s death, with many scrutinizing the brand’s 2015 decision to sever ties with Panettiere after she discussed her postpartum depression experience. The criticism continued even after Neutrogena issued an apology.This week's podcast episode digs into: Whether "canceling" a brand is actually possible today. Why there is more pressure on brands to address consumer criticism head on. Whether boycotts can hurt businesses in the long run.

Related episodes

Frequently asked about this episode

What does this episode say about brand & content?
Recognize that silence is no longer a viable crisis management strategy; it can worsen brand perception.
What does this episode say about dtc strategy?
Prioritize addressing consumer criticism head-on with transparency and genuine apologies to mitigate 'cancellation' attempts.
What does this episode say about brand & content?
Understand that social media amplifies brand missteps, making rapid and authentic responses critical for reputation management.
What does this episode say about brand & content?
Evaluate the potential for boycotts to inflict long-term damage, necessitating a strategy beyond short-term PR fixes.

Listen