The EcomCrew Ecommerce Podcast artwork

E626: How Fake Reviews Work Off-Amazon

The EcomCrew Ecommerce Podcast · with Allyse Slocum · December 3, 2025 · 30 min

Summary

This episode dissects the critical issue of fake reviews on independent platforms like Trustpilot, offering ecommerce operators a vital understanding of how these systems work, differentiate between review types, and combat fraudulent activity. Operators will learn actionable strategies to leverage authentic customer feedback, manage negative reviews, and build trust off-Amazon, ultimately safeguarding their brand reputation and fostering stronger customer relationships.

Key takeaways

Themes

customer trust & credibilityonline reputation managementreview management strategy

Topics covered

fake review detectionindependent review platformsmanaging negative reviewsoff-amazon review strategiesreview volume vs. ratingstore vs. product reviewstrustpilot functionality

Episode description

Dave interviews Allyse Slocum, the VP of Product @ Trustpilot, to talk about how fake reviews and review manipulation affect independent review platforms like Trustpilot. They explore how Trustpilot works, the difference between store and product reviews, and how Trustpilot handles fake reviews. Today's episode is sponsored by Sellerboard. Sellerboard helps users track sales, refunds and fees in real time, and even counts your indirect expenses in final profit. Beyond analytics, Sellerboard also streamlines operations with smart portfolios for PPC, inventory forecasting & management and more! Try Sellerboard free for 2 months — no credit card required. Just go to sellerboard.com/ecomcrew and get clarity on your margins today. Timestamps 00:00 - Introduction to Trustpilot 02:59 - Understanding Independent Review Platforms 05:57 - The Importance of Reviews Beyond Marketplaces 08:59 - Differentiating Store Reviews and Product Reviews 11:53 - The Value of Review Volume vs. Rating 15:04 - Navigating One-Star Reviews 18:06 - Addressing the Challenge of Fake Reviews 20:59 - Getting Started with Trustpilot If you'd like to connect with Allyse, you can check her out on LinkedIn! As always, if you have any questions or anything that you need help with, leave a comment down below if you're interested. Don't forget to leave us a review on iTunes if you enjoy our content. Thanks for listening! Until next time, happy selling!

Frequently asked about this episode

What does this episode say about customer trust & credibility?
Implement a strategy to actively solicit and manage both store and product reviews on independent platforms, understanding their distinct impact on customer perception.
What does this episode say about online reputation management?
Prioritize building review volume as much as striving for a high average rating, as a substantial quantity of authentic reviews signals credibility to potential customers.
What does this episode say about review management strategy?
Develop a clear process for addressing and responding to one-star reviews, viewing them as opportunities to demonstrate exceptional customer service and transparency.
What does this episode say about customer trust & credibility?
Investigate and potentially integrate with independent review platforms like Trustpilot to diversify your review strategy beyond marketplace-dependent systems and mitigate the risks of platform-specific review manipulation.
What does this episode say about customer trust & credibility?
Stay informed about the methods used by platforms to detect and combat fake reviews to better understand the integrity of the feedback you're receiving and displaying.

Listen