Silent Sales Machine Radio artwork

#991: Should you try to WIN the buy box or sell ABOVE the buy box on Amazon?

Silent Sales Machine Radio · with Grant Douglas · April 3, 2025 · 71 min

Summary

This episode demystifies the Amazon Buy Box, particularly for sellers grappling with pricing strategies. It challenges the conventional wisdom that winning the Buy Box is paramount, introducing a proven "above Buy Box" approach that allows sellers to achieve consistent sales and expand their ASIN catalog with less competitive products. E-commerce operators will learn to identify suitable products and implement nuanced pricing strategies for maximizing profit on Amazon, whether they target the Buy Box or strategically sell above it.

Key takeaways

Themes

amazon & marketplacesproduct & merchandisingsupply chain & operations

Topics covered

amazon buy box strategyselling above amazon buy boxamazon pricing strategiesproduct sourcing for amazonamazon asin diversificationreplenishment strategiesamazon fba profit margins

Episode description

Are you "buy box" obsessed when it comes to winning sales on Amazon?You don't have to be! You can win steady sales WITHOUT winning the buy box!   This strategy has been proven over and over in our community, but it's certainly not the ONLY strategy we love for building a beautiful business on Amazon!   It's true - we've been providing ample evidence for a couple years now that wise Amazon sellers and ProvenAmazonCourse.com students that you can completely ignore the buy box and sell easily sourced boring products for prices well above competing sellers who sell the same item, but...   In our excitement in sharing these examples sometimes our students are left with the impression that we favor this "above buy box" strategy above other fantastic pricing and sourcing strategies.   Let's get to the bottom of the confusion! Our Guest on today's show is a great coach on our team, Grant Douglas. He uses both strategies as does our host Jim. They discuss the benefits advantages and disadvantages of both winning the buy box as well as opening up the doors to millions of new ASINs instantly by playing with "above buy box" strategies.   Listen to our announcement at the end of this episode to get details about this special opportunity! ProvenAmazonCourse.com/100 - Our pre-conference workshop titled Path to 100 ASIN's - The Replens Accelerator. Brian and Robin Joy are teaching live in Orlando in May!   Watch this episode on our YouTube channel here: https://youtu.be/3vxd4s5PBFU     Show note LINKS: SilentJim.com/bb70 - see 200 examples of "above buy

Frequently asked about this episode

What does this episode say about amazon & marketplaces?
You don't always need to win the Amazon Buy Box to make consistent sales; a proven strategy exists to sell products above the Buy Box price.
What does this episode say about product & merchandising?
Successfully selling "above the Buy Box" often involves identifying easily sourced, "boring" products where competition is less fierce, allowing for higher profit margins.
What does this episode say about supply chain & operations?
Diversifying your Amazon strategy beyond always winning the Buy Box opens doors to millions of new ASINs, significantly expanding your product catalog potential.
What does this episode say about amazon & marketplaces?
Understand the advantages and disadvantages of both "winning the Buy Box" and "selling above the Buy Box" to apply the most effective strategy for different products.
What does this episode say about amazon & marketplaces?
Consider attending workshops like "Path to 100 ASIN's - The Replens Accelerator" to learn practical methods for expanding product offerings and mastering Amazon selling techniques from experienced coaches.

Listen