eCommerce Badassery artwork

361. What's a Good AOV? How to Set Realistic Goals + Smart Free Shipping Thresholds

eCommerce Badassery · January 27, 2026 · 9 min

Summary

This episode challenges common assumptions about Average Order Value (AOV) and free shipping thresholds. It emphasizes that a 'good' AOV is relative to a store's product assortment and pricing, not a fixed number. Ecommerce operators will learn how to strategically set AOV targets, implement effective cross-sells and upsells, and optimize free shipping thresholds to maximize profit, not just revenue.

Key takeaways

Themes

conversion & croproduct & merchandisingsupply chain & operations

Topics covered

average order value (aov) optimizationfree shipping thresholdsupselling and cross-selling strategiesproduct bundlingprofit margin analysisshopify shipping rules

Episode description

Inside the Lounge, we’ve been knee-deep in planning convos… and one theme keeps popping up over and over again: what’s a good average order value, how to increase it, and how to leverage your free shipping threshold without losing money. What we'll cover: The general rule I recommend for raising your AOV How to reverse-engineer your free shipping threshold based on your product prices The real deal on why profit matters more than revenue (yep, I said it) A cautionary tale about what happens when you don’t raise your free shipping threshold _______ Full Episode Show Notes http://ecommercebadassery.com/361 _______ Learn With Me Work with Me 1:1 https://ecommercebadassery.com/ecommerce-help/ https://ecommercebadassery.com/email-marketing/ Courses & Membership https://ecommercebadassery.com/membership https://ecommercebadassery.com/programs _______ Let's Connect Website: http://ecommercebadassery.com Instagram: http://instagram.com/ecommercebadassery Membership: http://ecommercebadassery.com/membership _______ Rate, Review, & Subscribe Like what you heard? I’d be forever grateful if you’d rate, review and subscribe to the show! Not only does it help your fellow eCommerce entrepreneurs find the eCommerce Badassery podcast; but it’s also valuable feedback for me to continue bringing you the content you want to hear. Review Here: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ecommerce-badassery/id1507457683

Related episodes

Frequently asked about this episode

What does this episode say about conversion & cro?
Your free shipping threshold should always be higher than your current AOV; adjust it upwards as your AOV increases.
What does this episode say about product & merchandising?
Implement cross-sells and upsells where the additional item is 30-40% of the original product price for higher conversion rates.
What does this episode say about supply chain & operations?
Focus on profit dollars over vanity revenue numbers when evaluating business performance, especially when adjusting shipping strategies.
What does this episode say about conversion & cro?
Consider product bundling or 'X for Y' deals to encourage increased spending, shifting the customer's psychology from buying another item for free shipping to getting a deal.
What does this episode say about conversion & cro?
Utilize tools like Smart Checkout Rules (e.g., on Shopify) to gain granular control over shipping methods based on cart contents, enabling more profitable fulfillment strategies.

Listen